Realism’s in the eye of the beholder

Life, oct. 28, 1920:

Thought-O for the day

Rather today, cartoon for the day 

(New York Times, 28 march 1926)

The chief impression I received last night was that Mr. Ingram has become neurotic, and is ridding himself of some of his inhibitions. The direction seemed totally uninspired and old fashioned.

Alice Terry and Antonio Moreno appeared passionless; the spectator could not feel sorry for them and their sorrows.

(Anabel Lane, The Film Mercury, 10 sept. 1926)

Battle Music

From Pictures and the Picturegoer, 7 oct. 1916, p. 25, Fred Adlington’s take on the music for Battle of the Somme (1916):

What if !

What if film conventions were set aside for a change ? Motion Picture Magazine of nov. 1927 suggests the following results:

Film Cartoon – news – 1924, or 2004 ?

From realist painter / cartoonist William Gropper, in Motion Picture Magazine, Feb. 1924, a little “edukational news” reel:

 

Film cartoon – more hokum !

One of the obsessions of film criticism in the 1920s was about film hookum. Motion Picture Magazine offers a good illustration of that: in the Feb. 1921 issue, G. Kauffman had already provided cartoon treatment to 4 “hokey” situations. Eldon Kelley is put to the task of illustrating yet another “hoke” story, by Frederick Van Vranken, in the July 1923 issue (“The Film Drama Versus Life”). 

Here are the six illustrations drawn by Kelley for the article (my favorites are #1 — because I’ve actually not seen it that often in silent films — and #5):

     

Film cartoons – ideas for censors, 1923

This from Leo Kober, 1923: “If I were Will Hays”….

Film cartoons – Olive Butter 1922

The Bioscope has another of those informative posts on where to find (mostly British) cartoons around the web for (mostly the 1910s) silent film period, and if you haven’t checked it out then you really should now.

My own contribution is more limited in scope: after Kaufman’s old hokum bucket comes a series of five witty cartoons by Olive Butter published in Motion Picture Magazine, april 1922, dealing with “Shadow-Drama in the South Seas” (yes I’m currently going through my pile of material xeroxed from the University of Southern California archives, and that includes all 1920s volumes of Motion Picture Magazine):

Enjoy!

    

 

Film cartoons – The Old Hokum Bucket

Today we relax with Motion Picture Magazine, February 1921, and four hokey situations that felt already old in 1921 (drawings by G. Francis Kauffman):